PDA

View Full Version : National commentary (AP) on Mesi


CoachC.
December 22nd, 2005, 12:26:08 AM
Mesi wins battle, but at what cost?
Damaged heavyweight boxer wins in a Nevada courtroom to fight again

By Tim Dahlberg
ASSOCIATED PRESS

Joe Mesi is smart and articulate. Not the kind of person you would think would risk scrambling his brains. Unfortunately, that's precisely what he plans to do.

The once promising heavyweight wants to get back in the ring and resume a boxing career that seemed ended for good 21 months ago. On Monday, he won a victory in a Las Vegas courtroom that could allow him to do just that.

"Christmas came early for me this year," Mesi said.

It did, but there are a lot of people in boxing who think Mesi should be careful before tearing the gift wrap off this present. Because, while allowing a guy to pursue his chosen profession shouldn't be a bad thing, there's a reason Mesi had to hire a bunch of high-priced lawyers to box once again.

It's called a subdural hematoma, which in layman's terms is blood clots on the surface of the brain. Mesi had at least two of them after his last fight in March 2004, when he had to pull himself off the canvas in the final round to salvage a win over Vassiliy Jirov.

Medical experts aren't exactly sure what causes a fighter to get a subdural hematoma, other than being hit in the head. What they do know is that it can be deadly. Two fighters in Las Vegas, including lightweight champion Leavander Johnson, died this year after suffering bleeding on the brain from fights.

That's why Nevada boxing authorities suspended Mesi's license to box, despite the contention of Mesi and his doctors that his brain had healed and there was no reason not to let him get back to his chosen profession.

"Maybe at the end of the day, it's the commission's job to throw in the towel for you," commissioner Dr. Tony Alamo told Mesi at a June hearing.

That towel got tossed back out of the ring when a judge ruled Mesi's medical suspension ended when his Nevada boxing license expired. It was a technical win, at best, because Nevada isn't likely to license Mesi again anyway.

"I'm just so thrilled," he said. "There were some days I woke up thinking how can they stop me and that I never was going to get a chance to fight again. Now I have that chance."

If you're not Mesi or his father, Jack, you have to wonder why the 32-year-old would want the chance at all.

Mesi says not to worry. He's got doctors who say his brain is healed, and he's not any more at risk of suffering another subdural hematoma than any other fighter.

"I have no doubt at all," he said. "I would have never wasted my time and effort if I had any doubts."

I, for one, still worry.

Maybe it's because I've been at ringside four different times and watched fighters die. Maybe it's because I've seen the heartache the family of those fighters went through.

I'll worry the first time Mesi steps back into the ring, and I'll worry if he eventually fights for the title. I'll worry about both Mesi and what could happen to the sport of boxing if a fighter with his stature and medical history happens to die.

Mesi's road back will be difficult, even if he remains healthy. His hope is that he gets a few fights under his belt, perhaps in Puerto Rico or some state that doesn't regulate the sport seriously, and then try to get licensed in New York for a fight in Buffalo.

A few fights more, and then maybe a heavyweight title fight. Mesi may not be the most talented fighter, but he is undefeated and packs a good punch. And the heavyweight division is lousy, at best.

"It won't be long before everybody is welcoming me," Mesi said.

Perhaps. When Mesi talks you have to listen to what he says.

He is a smart guy, after all.

Wing Eater
December 22nd, 2005, 3:40:14 AM
A real problem that this ruling is causing is that now many, many boxers are going to sue Nevada over their suspended licenses. Fighters who have been suspended for years are going to look for huge financial settlements for lost wages. I can't say I feel bad for Nevada (I've never been a big fan of their athletic commision), but the ruling could have unfortunate consequences for the state of boxing.

Billsman
December 26th, 2005, 6:24:58 PM
I wish him luck.

Scary Good
December 29th, 2005, 1:44:03 PM
I love Joe and I'm a huge fan. BUT, i'd be worried sick if he got another fight. It would be terrible if he started to take a couple bad shots to the head.

THATHURMANATOR
December 29th, 2005, 2:16:57 PM
I love the guy to and wish him the best. Hopefully he is right.